Hours & Location

Menus & Packages

Catering Info

At Baystar Catering we strive to make your special event one to remember. Every element has been carefully crafted with attention to detail.

We specialize in locally caught Florida seafood and hand cut steaks pairing them with the freshest ingredients available.

Our passion is to offer exceptional service and truly genuine hospitality to each and every guest. VIP treatment is standard as we create a memorable experience.

Our event planners will work with you to create a spectacular menu for you and your guests. We look forward to seeing you soon.

Interested in booking an
event at Island Way Grill?

Island Way Grill Event Menus PDF

Catering Info

•Plateware, waterglass, silverware rental $7.50 per person

•Linens not included

Staffed Events:
•20 person minimum

•events will be staffed with chefs, servers and bartenders as needed @ $125 per staff member.

•Staff amount to be determined with final guest count.

•Delivery and set up fee $75

•20 person minimum on delivery and set up, events to be within 15 miles to insure quality.

•All deliveries to include eco-friendly serve ware.
Disposable plates, napkins and silverware $1.50 per person

•Hot items served in aluminum pans.

•Wire chaffers and sternos upon request for an additional charge.

•7% sales tax and 22% staff gratuity to be applied on staffed events

•7% tax to be applied on deliveries.

Baystar Brunch

CHARCUTTERIE DISPLAY

assorted cheese / meats / grapes / crackers / fresh fruit & berries
spicy pecans / assorted Danish & muffins

CAPRESE SALAD

arugula / tomatoes / mozzarella / basil oil / balsamic

BAY SHRIMP COCKTAIL

cocktail sauce

CRANBERRY PECAN CHICKEN SALAD

BACON

FRENCH TOAST

bananas / pecans / foster sauce

QUICHE

broccoli cheese

BEEF SLIDERS

Bacon Jam, Arugula & White Cheddar

Assorted Sandwiches

Served Individual Boxes or Platters

SLICED SIRLOIN

white cheddar / horseradish cream

CRANBERRY NUT CHICKEN SALAD

CAPRESE

tomato / mozzarella / basil / pesto

HONEY HAM

swiss / mayo / mustard

house made chips & chocolate chip cookies

Lunch Selections

Plated Lunch Selections

Salad Selections

choice of one salad with plated lunch

Caesar Salad

Romaine / parmesan cheese / croutons / house Caesar dressing

Island Way House Salad

mixed greens / tomatoes / cucumbers / jicama / roasted pumpkin seeds / asiago carrots / cheese / house dressing

Island Way House Salad

mixed greens / tomatoes / cucumbers / jicama / roasted pumpkin seeds / asiago carrots / cheese / house dressing

SIDE SELECTIONS

choice of two

mashed potatoes
roasted herb fingerling potatoes
white cheddar mac and cheese
vegetable medley
green beans
glazed carrots

ENTRÉE SELECTIONS

PANKO CRUSTED HOG FISH

Key lime aioli

CHICKEN MARSALA

BEEF TIPS

mushroom marsala sauce

CHICKEN PICATTA

Please contact us for current pricing

Themed Buffets

BACKYARD BBQ

ISLAND SLAW

WATERMELON SALAD

feta cheese / mint / white balsamic

DEVILED EGGS

Traditional

PULLED PORK

mango bbq

CHICKEN THIGHS

orange glaze

CORN BREAD MUFFINS

MAC N’ CHEESE

LOBSTER BOIL

CAESER SALAD

Romaine / parmesan / croutons

GARLIC BREAD

MAIN EVENT

lobster tail / shrimp / andouille /
corn on the cob
herb fingerling potatoes / Old Bay Broth

FIESTA

HOUSE CHIPS & DIPS

salsa / guacamole

STREET TACOS

PORK
CHICKEN
pickled onions, fresh cilantro, cheese, pico, lime wedges

STREET CORN

chipotle crème / black pepper / cotija cheese

BLACK BEANS & CANTINA RICE

onions / fresh cilantro

QUESADILLAS

red onion / peppers / jack & cheddar cheese / shrimp

ITALIAN

CAESER SALAD

Romaine / parmesan / croutons

TOMATO MOZZARELLA

basil / balsamic reduction / pesto

MEATBALLS

marinara

GARLIC BREAD

CHICKEN PARMESEAN

penne pasta

SHRIMP ALFREDO

TAILGATE

BEEF SLIDERS

bacon jam / white cheddar / arugula

FRESH CATCH SLIDERS

key lime aioli

CHICKEN WINGS

cranberry jerk / mango bbq

LOADED POTATO SALAD

bacon / cheddar / chives

DEVILED EGGS

traditional

HOUSE MADE CHIPS

Please contact us for current pricing

Dinner Buffets

buffet selections

HORS D’OEUVRE

cheese assortment / crackers / bread sticks / nuts / strawberries pickles / fig jam / grapes

SALAD

(select one)

CAESER SALAD
romaine / parmesan / croutons

ISLAND SALAD
mixed greens / jicama / tomato / cucumber / carrots / asiago
roasted pumpkin seeds / vinaigrette

SIDES

(select two)

mashed potatoes
loaded mashed potatoes
roasted fingerling potatoes
green beans

vegetable medley
mac n’ cheese
honey glazed carrots

Traditional

ENTRÉES

4 oz - select two

BEEF TIPS

mushroom marsala

GRILLED CHICKEN

piccata – lemon/capers/white wine
caprese – tomato/basil/mozzarella/pesto
marsala – mushrooms/marsala sauce

GRILLED SALMON

pineapple salsa

Deluxe

ENTRÉES

4 oz - select two

BEEF TIPS

red wine demi

BRAISED SHORT RIBS

CHICKEN BREAST

piccata – lemon/capers/white wine
caprese – tomato/mozzarella, basil
marsala – mushrooms/marsala sauce

PORK

bacon wrapped/maple bourbon

MAHI

grilled/pineapple salsa

Premier

ENTRÉES

4 oz - select three

BEEF TENDERLOIN CARVING

horseradish cream

BRAISED SHORT RIBS

PORK

bacon wrapped/maple bourbon glaze

CHICKEN PICATTA

GROUPER

grilled/pineapple salsa

Butler Passed Appetizers

buffet selections

Tier one appetizers

BRUSCHETTA SELECTIONS

TOMATO PESTO
TUSCAN WHITE BEAN
ROASTED BEET AND GOAT CHEESE
FIG & GOAT CHEESE BRUSCHETTA
SCALLION CREAM CHEESE
TOMATO CAPRESE

HONEY CURRY CHICKEN FILO CUP

COCONUT GARNISH

CAPRESE SKEWERS

GRAPE TOMATO, MOZARELLA, FRESH BASIL
AND BALSAMIC REDUCTION

HOUSE PIMENTO CHEESE
IN FRIED WONTON

BAY SHRIMP COCKTAIL

tier two appetizers

SPICY TUNA

ENGLISH CUCUMBER CUP WITH SEAWEED GARNISH

CRAB SALAD

PHYLLO CUP

SMOKED SALMON

DILL, CRÈME FRAICHE, WATER CRACKER

SEARED BEEF TENDERLOIN

HORSERADISH CREMA, CARMELIZED ONION, CROSTINI

TUNA NACHO

AHI TUNA, GUACAMOLE, PICKLED JALAPENO,
HOUSE TORTILLA CHIP

SHRIMP COCKTAIL

COCKTAIL SAUCE

CHILI LIME SHRIMP

AVOCADO ON CUCUMBER SLICE

SMOKED GOUDA JALAPENOS WITH BACON

CRAB CAKES

SWEET PEPPER JELLY

PULLED CHICKEN

TOAST POINTS WITH CILANTRO AIOLI

FILET BITES

BLUE CHEESE ON SLIDED SEASONED SLICED POTATO

SHRIMP TEMPURA

COCKTAIL SAUCE

BAKED BRIE AND FRESH RASPBERRY IN PUFFED PASTRY

STUFFED MUSHROOMS ROCKEFELLER

MEATBALLS

MARINARA OR SWEET & SPICY KUNG PAO SAUCE

SHORT RIB EMPANADAS

JALAPENO CREMA

SEARED SCALLOP

BACON JAM

COCONUT SHRIMP

ORANGE GINGER MARMALADE

LOLLIPOP LAMB CHOP

BLACKENED SHRIMP AND GRITS

Platters & Displays

*PRICED AT 2 OF EACH OPTION PER GUEST

Tier one

ASSORTED CHEESE AND CRACKERS DISPLAY WITH GRAPES

Tier two

CHARCUTERIE DISPLAY

ASSORTED DOMESTIC AND IMPORTED CHEESES WITH SALAMI, NUTS, OLIVES, FRESH BERRIES, PICKLED VEGETABLES, SWEET PEPPER JELLY, ARTISIAN CRACKERS AND FLAT BREADS

SUSHI BOAT

SUSHI DISPLAY / GINGER / WASABI / SEAWEED SALAD

tier three

SHELLFISH STATION

FRESH SHUCKED YORK RIVER OYSTERS WITH CONDIMENTS
SHRIMP COCKTAIL
SCALLOP CEVICHE
SEAFOOD CEVICHE
MUSSELS

Dessert Stations

DESSERT STATION OPTIONS

ASSORTED COOKIES & BROWNIES

Chocolate Chip, White Chocolate Macadamia Nut, Rocky Road, Oatmeal Raisin, Chocolate Brownies

Mini Mousse Shooters Selections

Chocolate, Key Lime, Strawberry Bavarian, Peanut Butter

Assorted Mini Cup Cakes